xingzhengke
Hi guys
         first of all ,My Englist is very poor ,so you know am Chinese,and now I miss some problem with shatter,Can anyone help me?

I watch tutorials about Shatter and I test some times ,So cool !
by default ,Like Cube, spherer ,cylinder is eazy to shatter without problem,but if i use Maya Nurbs curve to make some poly geometry like wine glass,bowl it doesnt good work anymore,Like this:



please help me !  Thank you very very very very    much!


Click image for larger version - Name: cup01.jpg, Views: 44, Size: 45.84 KB Click image for larger version - Name: cup02.jpg, Views: 37, Size: 21.33 KB
Quote 0 0
pshipkov
Hi there,

i didn't check your scene, but it sounds like you are trying to shatter nurbs surfaces. You have to convert them to mesh and then it will be fine. Also if the conversion to mesh generates multiple mesh objects you have to poly-combine and merge the overlapping vertices. This will make it simpler later when you start shattering the stuff.

Quote 0 0
xingzhengke
thank you again :)
e  ,I am not use nurbs surface to shatter,I just use revolve to genrate a Polygon (in the revolve option down ,you can choice which geometry type you want,so i choice polygons )


Help me :)
Click image for larger version - Name: revolve_options.jpg, Views: 42, Size: 86.82 KB
Quote 0 0
pshipkov
Can you pass the scene please ?
Quote 0 0
xingzhengke
Yeah! i 'm uploaded my secens file already,please check my first  thread,just below the images,now,i add it again,you can download it here
Quote 0 0
pshipkov
I just realized that you are not talking about the shatter node not working at all, but failing to work properly in your case. Sorry for this late response.
I tested the shattering stuff with some pretty complicated geometry and all was right, but then somebody reported that it does not work for his "cup" case. I think you are hitting the same problem. I will have to check carefully what is going on there.

Quote 0 0
xingzhengke

Thanks a lot,I 'm so sorry about my poor English,But I think you know what I means now , ha ha ,help me please ,beacuse no people can help me in my friends,I am waiting to hear your good news

Quote 0 0
pshipkov
Are you locked to Maya only ?
There are other apps out there that can probably solve this particular case where the SOuP shatter node is failing on us.

Quote 0 0
xingzhengke
Thanks !I see ,cheers!

I just use Maya (with some plugin ,like blastcode ,and some scripts), Realflow and so on.

Quote 0 0
pshipkov
Check the attached archive. I used Houdini to shatter the geometry. Everything is there. Kind of embarrassing that SOuP shatter is failing in this case. Will have to address that sooner than later.

Quote 0 0
xingzhengke

don't embarrassed it ,beacues your great tools are free ! but your attached file are same as mine .

Quote 0 0
mordant
hello 
as i see it is an old bug since 2011
i have same problem in maya 2017 
when im trying to use  shatter after scatter on a cup or bottle so many extra faces will be created inside of bottle or cup
did u find any solution for the bug? 2017-04-17_22-23-00.png 
Quote 0 0
pshipkov
Shatter redux is in the plan for this year.
Quote 1 0

Add a Website Forum to your website.